Best puppy puzzle toys for providing mental stimulation

Give your pup a mental workout with these puzzle toys for puppies

best puppy puzzle toys

by Rosie Floyd |
Updated on

There are plenty of puppy toys that ensure your dog gets all the physical exercise they need, but when it comes to mental stimulation, there’s one type of toy that reigns supreme – and that’s puppy puzzle toys. While these types of toys will make sure your pup stays entertained, they’re so much more than just playthings. Puzzle toys for puppies will make sure your pup’s brain is challenged, aiding in the development of their cognitive skills and problem-solving abilities, all while keeping your pup engaged and happy. Let’s be honest, our pups will do just about anything if there’s food involved.

As any dog owner knows, ensuring your little bundle of fluff has plenty of playtime is important during puppyhood. Dogs are still developing during this stage so having a run around to chase and fetch is vital for muscle development, weight management and heart health, but what are their brain? Having toys to play with that make your puppy curious and use their intelligence to work out what’s going on is just as essential. That’s why puzzle toys are a great option because they’re interactive puppy toys that require your puppy to engage their brain and work out how to get those all-important treats out.

Best puppy puzzle toys at a glance:

• Best overall: Outward Hound Nina Ottosson Puppy Hide N' Slide – view on Amazon UK
• Best for longevity: Brightkins Spinning Hydrants Treat Puzzle for Pets – view on Amazon UK
• Best for puppies who love to fetch: Pets at Home Training Treat Ball Dog Toy – view on Pets at Home

You may be surprised to hear that playing with puzzle toys is a pretty tiring activity for young pups. As these toys have the allure of food, your pup will be less likely to give up playing with them until they’ve managed to get the reward at the end. All that extra brain power required for solving it means you’ll have a worn-out pup on your hands once they’ve got the treats in their belly. For certain puzzle toys, you can freeze doggy-safe peanut butter or Greek yoghurt on them, which will not only make them last longer but also serve as a dental care aid. While they’re not strictly teething toys for your puppy, frozen treats on aching gums can help to soothe them.

If you’re looking for a new way to stimulate your pup, consider puppy puzzle toys. There are varying levels of puzzles out there and some can even have the difficulty adjusted so you can challenge them further once they’ve got the hang of more beginner levels. We’ve got advice about introducing a puzzle to your puppy and more information about the benefits of playing with this type of toy in our FAQs section. Without any further ado, here are our top picks for the best puppy puzzles.

Best puppy puzzle toys

Best overall

Outward Hound Nina Ottosson Puppy Hide N' SlideAmazon

Rrp: $21.99

Price: $19.99
Alternative retailers
Petco$10.57View offer
PetSmart$19.99View offer
Wayfair$21.88View offer
Kohl's$24.99View offer

A fun hide-and-seek challenge that requires your pup to learn how combined actions lead to a tasty reward. Your pup will need to learn how to swivel the flippers and nudge the blocks along the Outward Hound Nina Ottosson Puppy Hide N' Slide to reveal the tasty treats inside. It's got a durable composite water design, meaning that it's BPA, PVC and Phthalate-free and you can easily wipe it clean between uses with warm water and soap.

Customer review: "Entertainment for all! We had so much fun watching her trying to work it out. She got it quite quickly but carried on playing with it for about an hour or so without any treats!
Well worth it for a bit of calm play instead of zoomies 😂"

Pros

  • Two types of challenges
  • No removable parts for safer play

Cons

  • Some reviews felt this puzzle wasn't challenging enough for their pup

Best for longevity

Brightkins Spinning Hydrants Treat Puzzle for PetsCredit: Rosie Floyd/Take a Break Pets

Rrp: $24.99

Price: $21.22
Alternative retailers
Walmart$10.39View offer
Target$12.99View offer
Tractor Supply$24.99View offer
PetSmart$24.99View offer

As you can adapt the difficulty of this Brightkins Spinning Hydrants Treat Puzzle for Pets, it should challenge your pup way into adulthood. You place treats inside the hydrants and then encourage your dog to use its nose and paws to spin the hydrants so the treats spill out. The tops of the hydrates can be twisted to make the treat holes partially or fully closed to make the puzzle more challenging.

Our review: "Bella is a very inquisitive puppy so I just knew she wouldn't be able to resist the lure of treats to play with this puzzle. To start with I sprinkled a couple of treats on the board to entice her in, but she soon came to realise there were more goodies inside the hydrants. Once she realised all she had to do was spin it to get the treats to come out, I upped the challenge and spun the hydrant lids around to fully close the treat hole. After that, she spent a good hour or so pawing them and nudging them with her nose until she'd fully got them out. As her owner, I like that this puzzle seems very robust, even after a bit of chewing while Bella was figuring out how to get the treats out, and it kept her mentally challenged for a while. She was absolutely exhausted afterwards!"

Pros

  • You can make this puzzle easier or more challenging
  • Robust

Cons

  • Be careful not to lose the removable parts

Best for puppies who love to fetch

Pets at Home Training Treat Ball Dog ToyPets at Home

If your pup loves nothing more than chasing after a ball, the Pets at Home Training Treat Ball Dog Toy may be the perfect puzzle for them. It has a small hole at each end of it that allows you to stuff some of your pup's favourite treats down. You can then watch as your pup bats it around with their paws to try and get to the goodies inside and chases around after it when it rolls across the floor. A great puzzle toy for providing a mental and physical workout.

Customer review: "Reuben, our Cockerpoo, is having such fun with this great ball, all round the lounge and kitchen. It rolls really well and the treats only come out occasionally which is a good thing. He gets really annoyed if it goes under the table and behind curtains and barks until someone comes and rescues it. Great value for the money."

Pros

  • Offers mental and physical stimulation
  • Perfect for puppies who love to chase and fetch

Cons

  • Could be more robust

Best slow feeding puppy puzzle

If your pup has a tendency to wolf down their food as quickly as they can, you may want to try feeding them their meals from this SUOXU Dog Puzzle. There are many compartments to hide kibble in so you can definitely fit their full portion inside. As there are puzzles involved to get to their dinner, it will encourage your puppy to eat more slowly, preventing them from gulping it down and promoting better digestion. The plastic sliders covering each department are non-detachable to avoid swallowing.

Customer review: "Our little TT pup love this & keeps her amused for ages. We use it as a treat after the first walk of the day & also last thing at night when it's bed time. We use treats chopped up as well as good quality dry puppy food. We have used it with her raw food as she can be a bit fussy when eating"

Pros

  • Great for fast eaters
  • Non-detachable parts

Cons

  • Some reviewers felt it could be more durable

Best for teething puppies

This versatile PetLove Nuzzle Puzzle Puppy Banana can be stuffed with treats and filled with spreads for a fun filled boredom-busting treat. Made from rubber, the soft material is perfect for puppy teeth and the toy is designed so you can freeze it so it's extra soothing for your pup to gnaw on. Not only can you use it as a food puzzle, but it's great for fetch games as it bounces in random directions and it also floats so you can use it for water play too.

Customer review: "You can stuff this with paste or soft treats either way keeps your dog entertained for ages - paste works well as they have to really work hard to get it out as the banana keeps closing itself."

Pros

  • Multiple ways to play
  • Bright colour so easily seen

Cons

  • Not as robust as other puppy puzzle toys

Best puppy puzzle for beginners

Nina Ottosson Smart Interactive Treat Puzzle Puppy ToyPets at Home

Get your pup excited about playing problem-solving games for the first time with the Nina Ottosson Smart Interactive Treat Puzzle Puppy Toy. It features nine treat-hiding compartments that can be covered over, with the scent of treats coming through the hole at the top. As a simple puzzle, your pup only needs to nudge or pow the bones to uncover the treats underneath so it's a great one to introduce your pup to puzzle games.

Pros

  • Reduce boredom and destructive behaviour
  • Suitable for any breed and size

Cons

  • Might be too easy for some puppies

Best for variety

Nina Ottosson Puppy Lickin' Layers Interactive Puzzle Game and Slow FeederPets at Home

A great one to use with either wet or dry puppy food, the Nina Ottosson Puppy Lickin' Layers Interactive Puzzle Game and Slow Feeder offers three layers of food compartments for your puppy to reveal. It encourages your pup to build on their problem-solving skills as they work out how to move each layer to find the hidden treats. Not only is this puzzle game good for boredom-busting but it also improves digestion if used as a slow feeder as the mazes and ridges on each layer force your pup to eat at a safer, healthier pace.

Customer review: "A very well made slow puzzle feeder that not only slows a ravenous puppy down, it also exercises its brain. So much better than other feeders I have bought in the past."

Pros

  • Different levels to keep puppies engaged for longer
  • Doubles up as a slow feeder

Cons

  • May take your pup a while to get a hang of it compared to other puzzles on our list

Best for mental stimulation

Trixie Dog Activity Turn AroundAmazon
Price: $9.45
Alternative retailers
Walmart$36.75View offer

By turning the elements of this Trixie Dog Activity Turn Around, your puppy will get the treats so they'll need to nudge the tubes with their head and paw at them until the tube flips and the rewards get released It includes two different cap sizes for the turning tubes so you can adjust the difficulty to suit your pup's abilities. This puzzle is great for keeping your hound's mind active as it will stimulate them and help with their concentration.

Customer review: "Bought this for my 6 month old puppy and after a few tries he was able to work out how to get the treats and it kept him occupied for ages - well until the food was gone."

Pros

  • Two difficulty levels
  • Great for mental stimulation

Cons

  • Stability could be better

FAQs

Are puzzle toys good for puppies?

Puzzle toys are good for puppies in several different ways. They provide mental stimulation as they have to use their brain to work out how to get the treats inside and because of this, they’re great for developing a puppy’s problem-solving skills too. They’re also a great boredom-buster as they take a good amount of time to complete, keeping your little pup entertained for ages. Not to mention, puzzle toys are also good for slowing down those pups who are fast eaters at mealtimes. You can put their meals inside a puzzle to turn chow-down time into a mentally engaging activity.
It's important to remember that puzzles aren't puppy chew toys so you should remove them if your pup is showing signs of being destructive. For this reason, you should always supervise your pup while they're playing with a puzzle.

How do you introduce a puzzle to a puppy?

Like everything you do with a puppy, you need to introduce a puzzle to a puppy slowly and gradually. You’ll want to start by demonstrating to them how the puzzle works and where the treats are. You’ll also want to pick a simple puzzle to begin with that is easy for them to solve so they associate completing it with getting a reward, making them want to come back for more.
When they interact with the puzzle, be sure to shower your pup with plenty of praise (especially when they’re making progress in completing the puzzle) so they make that positive connection with it. As your pup gets to grips with the puzzle and completes it in record time, you can increase the difficulty to keep them engaged.

Do puppy puzzle toys tire out puppies?

You may not associate playing with a puzzle toy as an exhausting activity, but puppy puzzle toys will tire your puppy out mentally. Think of playing with puzzle toys as an exercise for your puppy’s mind. They challenge them and encourage them to build on their problem-solving skills, which tires out their little brains. Having this mental stimulation is vital for a puppy’s overall well-being and helps them burn some of their mental energy, which you’ll definitely be thankful for when it comes to settling down for bedtime.

Do puppies get frustrated with puppy puzzle toys?

If a puzzle is too challenging, some puppies may display some frustrating behaviours. It’s important to keep an eye on your pup while they’re playing with a puzzle toy and if they’re showing destructive behaviours, you should intervene and perhaps take the toy away from them.
Signs that your puppy may be frustrated with a puzzle toy include:
• Whining or being overall vocal
• Pawing or scratching at the toy or you
• Excessive barking
• Restlessness and generally being fidgety
• Avoiding or withdrawing away from the puzzle
• Chewing the puzzle or surrounding furniture, shoes or other items
• Biting or mouthing more than usual
To avoid these behaviours, you should also make sure that you’re getting them to play with an age-appropriate puzzle and one that is best suited to their abilities. You can always start with an easy puzzle and gradually move on to a trickier one as your puppy gets the hang of it.

puzzle toys for puppies
Bella the Cockapoo pawing at the a puppy puzzle toy. Credit: Rosie Floyd/Take a Break Pets ©Credit: Rosie Floyd/Take a Break Pets

Rosie Floyd is a Pets, Homes and Garden Product Writer for Take A Break Pets, specialising in all things dogs. She grew up always having at least one dog as part of the family and has experience in owning a variety of breeds, including Labradors, Cockapoos and Yorkshire Terriers.

Just so you know, we may receive a commission or other compensation from the links on this website - read why you should trust us